40 Bay Street, Brighton, VIC 3186 | Property Value & History | OnTheHouse
OFF MARKET

40 Bay Street
Brighton VIC 3186

Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 4
Car spaces: 2
Floor area: 600m2
Land area: 1982m2
Estimated Value & Rent
Estimated Value
Estimated Rent
Confidence
Last updated 22 Dec 2025
Low

High
Save

Property Details for 40 Bay St, Brighton

40 Bay St, Brighton is a 5 bedroom, 4 bathroom House with 2 parking spaces and was built in 1860. The property has a land size of 1982m2 and floor size of 600m2. While the property is not currently for sale or for rent, it was last sold in November 2015.

Building Type
House
Year Built
1860
Floor Size
600m2
Land Size
1982m2
Local Government
Bayside
Lot/Plan
8/LP73025

Last Listing description (December 2015)

A private estate on approx 1960 sqm offering a truly unique lifestyle with private secluded gardens featuring a classic colonial style residence.
Beautiful gardens elevate the tranquillity with dry stone walls contrasting against rolling green lawn framed with towering Magnolia trees. A deep northern verandah frames the elegant facade and provides a beautiful space for entertaining with family and friends in the sunshine; while an expansive rear courtyard garden with a huge gas heated swimming pool is a fabulous area for endless Summer fun.
The grandeur of the home's 1860s origins are rarely replicated in modern homes with ceilings rising over four metres, huge wall expanses perfect for an art collection and superb room dimensions. With 14 principal rooms and five living areas from richly elegant reception rooms to relaxing family spaces, the home provides rooms for the family to come together or enjoy their own private space. The original stables and coach house have been converted into a versatile retreat crowned with a fifth bedroom perfect for teenagers or guests.

Five bedrooms and three bathrooms include the palatial main bedroom overlooking the northern garden with a separate dressing room and en suite with clawfoot bath.
Original period detail has been respectfully restored from marble fireplaces with gas inserts to lime washed Baltic floorboards and intricate ceiling roses. Modern appointments from remote gates to a double carport, hydronic heating, alarm system, designer Hub light fittings and a desalination plant ensure every contemporary comfort.
Benarty is a once in a lifetime opportunity to acquire one of Brighton's most unique estates walking distance to the beach and Bay Street shopping with a choice of schools nearby.

Property History for 40 Bay St, Brighton, VIC 3186

A timeline of how this property has performed in the market
Last Sold
$5,800,000
06 Nov 2015
  • 17 Nov 2018
    Listed for Sale Not Disclosed
  • 06 Nov 2015
    Sold for $5,800,000
  • 06 Aug 2015
    Listed for Sale Not Disclosed
Sign in to see more transactions
Commute Calculator

About Brighton 3186

The size of Brighton is approximately 8.4 square kilometres. It has 22 parks covering nearly 10.9% of total area. The population of Brighton in 2016 was 23253 people. By 2021 the population was 23252 showing a stable population in the area during that time. The predominant age group in Brighton is 50-59 years. Households in Brighton are primarily couples with children and are likely to be repaying over $4000 per month on mortgage repayments. In general, people in Brighton work in a professional occupation.In 2021, 73.20% of the homes in Brighton were owner-occupied compared with 72.10% in 2016.

Brighton has 14,237 properties. Over the last 5 years, Houses in Brighton have seen a 9.63% increase in median value, while Units have seen a 11.07% increase. As at 30 November 2025:

  • The median value for Houses in Brighton is $3,207,489 while the median value for Units is $1,172,947.
  • Houses have a median rent of $1,350 while Units have a median rent of $760.
There are currently 28 properties listed for sale, and 11 properties listed for rent in Brighton on OnTheHouse. According to Cotality's data, 686 properties were sold in the past 12 months in Brighton.

Suburb Insights for Brighton 3186

Market Insights
Brighton Trends for Houses
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Brighton Trends for Units
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Neighbourhood Insights
Age
Household
Occupancy
No data to show
Cotality Copyright and Legal Disclaimers about Property Data
Disclaimer
The Cotality Data provided in this publication is of a general nature and should not be construed as specific advice or relied upon in lieu of appropriate professional advice.

While Cotality uses commercially reasonable efforts to ensure the Cotality Data is current, Cotality does not warrant the accuracy, currency or completeness of the Cotality Data and to the full extent permitted by law excludes all loss or damage howsoever arising (including through negligence) in connection with the Cotality Data.