12 Wagstaffe Avenue, Wagstaffe, NSW 2257 sold on 26 September 2025 | OnTheHouse
SOLD
Sold on 26 Sep 2025 for $2,430,000

12 Wagstaffe Avenue
Wagstaffe NSW 2257

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2
Car spaces: 1
Save

Property Details for 12 Wagstaffe Ave, Wagstaffe

12 Wagstaffe Ave, Wagstaffe is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom House with 1 parking spaces and was built in 1901. While the property is not currently for sale or for rent, it was last sold in September 2025. There are other 4 bedroom House sold in Wagstaffe in the last 12 months.

Building Type
House
Year Built
1901
Local Government
Central Coast
Lot/Plan
682/DP737089

Last Listing description (April 2025)

Absolutely Captivating Blend of Charm and Style with Water Views

Back in 1913, when Wagstaffe was just a quiet fishing village, its residents came together to build an Anglican Church right near the shoreline; it's an iconic piece of the area's history and still stands today at 12 Wagstaffe Avenue.

Heritage listed and now in private ownership, it's been carefully renovated and extended to capture much of timeless character of the original, while designing a family home that pairs contemporary comfort with style and flair. The church and its sunroom extension function as the main living/dining and kitchen areas; the space is gorgeous with sky-high timber ceilings, exposed trusses and its restored hardwood floors polished to a high sheen. A contemporary addition sits right behind, creating a pavilion design around the sun-washed decks and swim spa. The new extension includes a family room, two bedrooms and a gorgeous, top-floor master suite.

The water views are lovely, especially from the sunroom warm and bright in winter, and breezy all summer long. It's an amazing spot to watch the weather roll in. It's just steps from the local school and shop, with Palm Beach ferry wharf, fishing jetties, and swimming spots just moments from the door.

Architecturally renovated and redesigned by Fiona Brodie in 2012
Character rich; impossible to replicate this level of craftsmanship
Soaring, open interiors; stunning layout for living and entertaining
Idyllic views across the waterfront and just 100m from the shoreline
Cathedral ceilings, exposed beams/trusses, gleaming hardwood floors
Contemporary CaesarStone/island kitchen, high-quality appliances
Full-length sunroom, separate family room in the new extension
Alfresco entertaining decks and 5.2m swim spa; stunning gardens
Top-floor master suite with walk-in robe and views to Pretty Beach
Air conditioning, wood burning fireplace, guest w/c, carport
Stroll to Wagstaffe wharf, Shop, Pretty Beach School and Lobster Beach
1hr 45 minutes' drive to Sydney CBD and 30 minutes to Gosford

To register for the online auction, please copy and paste the link below into your browser:-

https://widget.auctionslive.com/widget/auctions/view/199261/PXq

Property History for 12 Wagstaffe Ave, Wagstaffe, NSW 2257

A timeline of how this property has performed in the market
Last Sold
$2,430,000
26 Sep 2025
  • 01 Oct 2024
    Listed for Sale Guide $2,300,000
  • 14 Oct 2017
    Listed for Sale For Sale, price guide $1,550,000 - $1,650,000
  • 04 Jun 2014
    Listed for Sale OFFERS OVER $950,000
Sign in to see more transactions
Commute Calculator

About Wagstaffe 2257

The size of Wagstaffe is approximately 0.8 square kilometres. It has 1 park covering nearly 22.5% of total area. The population of Wagstaffe in 2016 was 222 people. By 2021 the population was 240 showing a population growth of 8.1% in the area during that time. The predominant age group in Wagstaffe is 60-69 years. Households in Wagstaffe are primarily childless couples and are likely to be repaying not stated per month on mortgage repayments. In general, people in Wagstaffe work in a professional occupation.In 2021, 85.90% of the homes in Wagstaffe were owner-occupied compared with 91.10% in 2016.

Wagstaffe has 206 properties. Over the last 5 years, Houses in Wagstaffe have seen a 48.40% increase in median value. As at 31 October 2025:

  • The median value for Houses in Wagstaffe is $1,754,922 while the median value for Units is $1,139,057.
There are currently 6 properties listed for sale, and no properties listed for rent in Wagstaffe on OnTheHouse. According to Cotality's data, 7 properties were sold in the past 12 months in Wagstaffe.

Suburb Insights for Wagstaffe 2257

Market Insights
Wagstaffe Trends for Houses
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Wagstaffe Trends for Units
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Neighbourhood Insights
Age
Household
Occupancy
No data to show
Cotality Copyright and Legal Disclaimers about Property Data
Disclaimer
The Cotality Data provided in this publication is of a general nature and should not be construed as specific advice or relied upon in lieu of appropriate professional advice.

While Cotality uses commercially reasonable efforts to ensure the Cotality Data is current, Cotality does not warrant the accuracy, currency or completeness of the Cotality Data and to the full extent permitted by law excludes all loss or damage howsoever arising (including through negligence) in connection with the Cotality Data.