23 Arthur Street, Mittagong, NSW 2575 | Property Value & History | OnTheHouse
OFF MARKET

23 Arthur Street
Mittagong NSW 2575

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2
Car spaces: 1
Floor area: 92m2
Land area: 1020m2
Estimated Value & Rent
Estimated Value
Estimated Rent
Confidence
Last updated 22 Dec 2025
Low

High
Save

Property Details for 23 Arthur St, Mittagong

23 Arthur St, Mittagong is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom House with 1 parking spaces. The property has a land size of 1020m2 and floor size of 92m2. While the property is not currently for sale or for rent, it was last sold in March 2023.

Building Type
House
Floor Size
92m2
Land Size
1020m2
Local Government
Wingecarribee
Lot/Plan
34/C/DP20

Last Listing description (May 2023)

Built in the mid-1800s, this charming cottage is one of the original homesteads in Mittagong and has been sympathetically restored and extended to enhance its heritage charm while providing the creature comforts of the 21 st Century. The cottage sits in a prime location, just a stone's throw from Lake Alexandra and an easy walk to cafes, schools and shops. While the home is reaped in history and bears an important connection to the original families and businesses of the area, it is not heritage listed, giving the new owners the scope to make the home their own.

A secret garden oasis of mature trees, camelias, and flowering bulbs line the paths leading to the homestead. The garden features a cubby house, shed, outdoor pizza oven and 100-year-old wisteria overhanging the pergola.

The master bedroom features a walk-in robe and access to an additional storage room, while the two guest bedrooms are spacious and have views overlooking the garden. The living room, dining room and kitchen centre around an original stone fireplace. The kitchen has a large freestanding Belling double oven with gas cooktop, a walk-in pantry as well as an antique island bench with Carrara marble top.

With stained glass windows, semi-vaulted ceilings, original timber floors and period detailing throughout, the Lakeside cottage it is the perfect mix of historic country living and modern conveniences.

The cottage sits on a 1,012sqm block with rear-lane access to a single garage with internal access.
Three bedrooms, main with large walk-in robe and access to an additional storage area.
Formal sitting room with gas fireplace with feature tiling and original mantel.
Spacious living, dining and kitchen with reverse cycle a/c centres around the old stone fireplace complete with a 1904 addition of a 'Bega' woodfired oven.
Large kitchen with timber cabinets, walk-in pantry, antique island bench with marble top, freestanding gas cooktop and dual oven, and a new Bosch dishwasher.
Two bathrooms, one featuring the home's original clawfoot bath.

Property History for 23 Arthur St, Mittagong, NSW 2575

A timeline of how this property has performed in the market
Last Sold
$1,260,000
21 Mar 2023
Listed for Rent
21 Mar 2023
  • 21 Mar 2023
    Sold for $1,260,000
  • 27 Feb 2023
    Listed for Rent $750 / week
  • 10 Nov 2022
    Listed for Sale Guide $1,300,000 - $1,350,000
Sign in to see more transactions
Commute Calculator

About Mittagong 2575

The size of Mittagong is approximately 60.5 square kilometres. It has 12 parks covering nearly 20.4% of total area. The population of Mittagong in 2016 was 5767 people. By 2021 the population was 6090 showing a population growth of 5.6% in the area during that time. The predominant age group in Mittagong is 60-69 years. Households in Mittagong are primarily childless couples and are likely to be repaying $1800 - $2399 per month on mortgage repayments. In general, people in Mittagong work in a professional occupation.In 2021, 67.80% of the homes in Mittagong were owner-occupied compared with 69.30% in 2016.

Mittagong has 3,737 properties. Over the last 5 years, Houses in Mittagong have seen a 31.73% increase in median value, while Units have seen a 24.12% increase. As at 30 November 2025:

  • The median value for Houses in Mittagong is $1,067,943 while the median value for Units is $739,944.
  • Houses have a median rent of $650 while Units have a median rent of $620.
There are currently 39 properties listed for sale, and 29 properties listed for rent in Mittagong on OnTheHouse. According to Cotality's data, 152 properties were sold in the past 12 months in Mittagong.

Suburb Insights for Mittagong 2575

Market Insights
Mittagong Trends for Houses
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Mittagong Trends for Units
Median Value

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Growth

N/A

View Trend
Median Rent

N/A

-
View Trend
Rental Yield

N/A

-
View Trend
Median Value: The middle value of all properties across the geography based on the Automated Valuation Model.


Median Value over 1 year
Neighbourhood Insights
Age
Household
Occupancy
No data to show
Cotality Copyright and Legal Disclaimers about Property Data
Disclaimer
The Cotality Data provided in this publication is of a general nature and should not be construed as specific advice or relied upon in lieu of appropriate professional advice.

While Cotality uses commercially reasonable efforts to ensure the Cotality Data is current, Cotality does not warrant the accuracy, currency or completeness of the Cotality Data and to the full extent permitted by law excludes all loss or damage howsoever arising (including through negligence) in connection with the Cotality Data.